Stop 7 of 9 · Why does the Dirac operator on T³ see eight corners?
The eight doublers — hopping, Dirac and their sum
The hopping H = −2t T° moves an excitation from site to site; its energy −2t Σ cos vanishes on a whole plane of momenta. With the Kogut–Susskind signs the three axes anticommute and the energy becomes a length, ±√(Σ cos² + m²): it vanishes at one point only, where the eight doublers sit, the corners (±π/2)³. The square is the sum of the three axes, D² = T_x² + T_y² + T_z² + m².
Now close a fourth, small axis: a ring of three positions, the fibre w. Its turning modes act as a mass of ½.
Two things follow: no energy is ever smaller than ½ (a mass gap), and, because the other axes are closed too,
no state of definite energy moves faster than 1/φ = 0.618… of the light cone. Further down, slide the mass and watch both appear.
The torus: the hopping state
size |Ψ|² · colour phaseThe spectral star
⟨cos⟩ on each axis, spread of the cosineThe eight doublers, spectral side: hopping, Dirac and their sum
follows the torus, the mode and Ψ(s) above · drag any panel to turn allEverything here is the torus above, at the same time: its modes, the occupied mode (○), Ψ(s) (●, at
⟨cos⟩ on each axis, at ⟨cos²⟩ in the squares) and the turn. Every mode (a, b, c) of the torus sits at (cos θa, cos θb, cos θc)
in the cube of cosines. The hopping E = −2t Σ cos vanishes on a whole plane, Σ cos = 0. With the
Kogut–Susskind signs the three axes anticommute and the energy becomes a length,
E = ±√(cos²θa + cos²θb + cos²θc + m²): it vanishes at one point only, the origin,
where the eight doublers (±π/2)³ sit. The square root turns the zero plane of the hopping into the zero point
of Dirac. Below, their sum: in the squares (cos², cos², cos²) the Dirac energy squared is the sum of the
three axes, D² = Tx² + Ty² + Tz² + m². The fibre of 3 positions gives the mass
½: the origin opens into the gap |E| ≥ ½.
Hopping: E = −2t Σ cos, zero on a plane
Dirac: E = ±√(Σ cos² + m²), zero at one point
Sum: the squares, E² − m² = cos² + cos² + cos²
Lean (nrs3-tritoro): TorusDirac3.dirac3_sq
(Dm² = Tx² + Ty² + Tz² + m² on T³, even sizes), the anticommutations
Tx_Ay, Tx_Az, Ay_Az, eps_Tx, eps_Ay, eps_Az, and
dirac3_wave (the eight waves (±i)x(±i)y(±i)z are zero modes of
D₀, and the mass sends each to the opposite corner). The spectrum of each ring is the Lean
TorusSpectrum.eq_cos_of_eigenvector. The fibre as fourth axis is TorusFiberDirac.dirac_sq; its rotating modes give the mass ½ and the gap
(TorusFiberDirac.dirac_doublers, TorusFiberDirac.abs_energy_ge).
The mass gap and the speed limit
Take one closed axis and a mass m. Each state has a momentum k and an energy on one of two bands,
E = ±√(cos²k + m²). Its velocity is the slope of its band. With m = 0 the bands touch (the doublers) and the slope reaches
the light cone. With a mass a gap opens, the bands round off, and no slope can exceed r = √(1 + m²) − m. The fibre gives
m = ½, and then r = 1/φ: the same number as the largest tension of a minimum-uncertainty state of four positions.
The hopping band of every ring
Each ring of d positions has hopping eigenvalues −2t cos(2πm/d),
m = 0, …, d − 1. They fill [−2|t|, 2|t|] and touch both ends: m = 0 gives
−2t, and for even d the alternating mode gives +2t. ○ the occupied mode ·
● ⟨H⟩ of Ψ(s), with the spread σH. At s = 0 the state is one site and
⟨H⟩ = 0 with the spread open. At s = 1 the dot sits on the mode and the spread closes.
Press Tour to stay on one torus, Hop to pause.
The octahedron of the band
drag to turn · dashed: the band edgePut a vertex at ±1 on every axis: that octahedron is the whole cosine band,
|λ| ≤ 1 on each ring, the same bound for every size (TorusSpeed.abs_energy_le_one).
The inner octahedron has vertices at the occupied |cos(2πm/d)|. On the canonical
3 × 3 × 3 the modes are 1 and −1/2, so a single axis occupies either the
outer vertex or 1/2. The star page draws δ, the unresolved share. This octahedron draws
the resolved spectrum.
Energy spread against position spread
σH against σP, one panel per axisThe complement of the tension plot. As s runs from the site to the mode,
σH falls and σP rises. At s = 1 the mode is an
eigenvector of H, so σH = 0 and the position fills the ring. At
s = 0 the site is an eigenvector of P, so σP = 0 and the
energy fills the neighbours. The product stays positive in between: concentrating one observable opens the other.
| axis | positions | m | cos(2πm/d) | ε = −2t cos | ⟨H⟩(s) | σH(s) | σP(s) |
|---|
What is exact here
- Lean The four operators of the staggered Dirac operator anticommute.
- Lean
D_m² = T_x² + T_y² + T_z² + m²on T³ with even sizes, and on the open cube for every size. - Lean When 4 divides every size, the eight waves
(±i)ˣ(±i)ʸ(±i)ᶻare zero modes ofD₀; the mass sends each to the opposite corner. - Lean The spectrum of each ring is
cos(2πm/d). - Lean With the fibre as a fourth closed axis,
D₄² = T_x² + T_y² + T_z² + T°_w², and the fibre acts as a mass:½on its turning modes,1on the uniform one. - Lean Mass gap: every energy has
|E| ≥ ½, on the fibred box and onT³ × w, for every state; the doublers reach it. - Lean Speed limit: a state of definite energy and mass
mmoves at most at√(1 + m²) − |m|; onT³ × wthat is1/φalong each axis. - Lean That
1/φis the largest tension of a minimum-uncertainty state of four positions, for one exact reason:φ − 1/φ = 2·½. - Open The index count of the doublers (Nielsen–Ninomiya) is the classical theorem, not yet in Lean.
Theorem trail
| Statement | Name |
|---|---|
| anticommutation | TorusDirac3.Tx_Ay, TorusDirac3.Tx_Az, TorusDirac3.Ay_Az |
D_m² on T³ and on the open cube | TorusDirac3.dirac3_sq, OpenDirac.dirac_sq |
| the eight doublers | TorusDirac3.dirac3_wave |
| the spectrum of the ring | TorusSpectrum.eq_cos_of_eigenvector |
| the fibre as fourth axis | TorusFiberDirac.dirac_sq, TorusFiberDirac.dirac_tensor |
mass gap |E| ≥ ½ | FiberDirac.abs_energy_ge, TorusFiberDirac.abs_energy_ge, TorusFiberDirac.dirac_doublers |
speed limit √(1 + m²) − |m|, any space | DiracSpeed.abs_velocity_le, DiracSpeed.speedLimit_half, DiracSpeed.speedLimit_sinh |
1/φ on the three axes of T³ × w | TorusFiberDirac.abs_velocity_le_inv_goldenRatio_axes |
the same 1/φ as minimum uncertainty | MinUncertaintyFiber.isGreatest_minUncertaintyTension |